Should I stay or should I go? State Exits from Regional Organizations

Funding: Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft 

Principal Investigator: Prof. Dr. Diana Panke

Reseach Associates: Lukas Grundsfeld, Pawel Tverskoi

Research Assistants: Léonie Berton, Antonia Damm, Tim Rauschenberg, Mirjam Schellinger, Martin Stoll, Tim Vent

(from left to right: Lukas Grundsfeld, M.A., Prof. Dr. Diana Panke, Pawel Tverskoi, M.A.) 

Abstract

The withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union (EU) recently made headlines, attracting a lot of public and scholarly attention. BREXIT is not the only instance in which a member state exited a regional organization (RO). In fact, there were 55 withdrawals from ROs between the years 1945-2022. Studying these withdrawals is important as they can harm international cooperation and potentially trigger further disintegration in the longer run that could even endanger the multilateral world order as we know it.

Not all states are equally inclined to leave ROs. In fact, the withdrawals from ROs are mainly driven by smaller states. Also, while some ROs were subject to several withdrawals (e.g. Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa), others experienced just one exit (e.g. the EU) and yet others never lost members (e.g. MERCOSUR). Whereas there is work on state exits from IOs, major findings, do not travel to ROs. As of yet, we do not know why states leave ROs and why some ROs are subject to more withdrawals than others, although understanding exits is of great importance for society and scholars alike. Thus, this project seeks to uncover the reasons behind the phenomenon of state exits from ROs and addresses the research questions:

1. Why are some states more inclined to exit ROs than others?
2. Why are some ROs more prone to state withdrawals than others?

Conference Contributions

• ·     Panke, Diana, Grundsfeld, Lukas, and Tverskoi, Pawel (2023) "Ending Cooperation: A Comparative Analysis of State Exits from Regional International Organizations", paper presented at the European Union Studies Association’s 18^th Biennial Conference, Pittsburgh, May 2023.

• Panke, Diana (2023) "Populist and Nationalist Challenges All the Way? Why Member States Withdraw from Regional organizations", paper presented at the European Union Studies Association’s 18^th Biennial Conference, Pittsburgh, May 2023.
• Panke, Diana, Grundsfeld, Lukas, and Tverskoi, Pawel (2023): "Ending Cooperation: A Comparative Analysis of State Exits from Regional International Organizations", paper presented at the International Studies Association's Annual Convention, Montréal, March 2023.